The internet is a buzz with discussions about the Lost finale last night. Some people are disappointed, some are satisfied, some are angry, and most of us are just still thinking. In fact, I have to say that everytime I woke up last night, I was thinking about the finale and its meaning.
What struck me this morning, while I was perusing Facebook comments on the subject, was the fact that so many Christians were disappointed that the finale did not deliver a more theologically sound conclusion. My first reaction to this was to roll my eyes and sigh dramatically. Come on Christians, did you really expect a show with mere undertones of spirituality to deliver a Biblical perspective on the afterlife (or life for that matter)?
My reaction throughout the day to disappointed Christians remains the same, but I’ve formulated my thoughts as the day has progressed.
Why Christians shouldn’t be disappointed with the Lost finale….
We shouldn’t be disappointed with Lost because the writers/producers never promised us theological accuracy. If there are open Christ followers on the writing team, I’ve certainly never heard about it, and I think we would have heard about it by now. Come on, J.J. Abrams never said he was the next C.S. Lewis or J.R. Tolkien. Similarly, the writers/producers of Lost never said that it was an allegory. Yet for some reason Christians have been trying to force Lost into an allegorical box. We’ve done the same thing to Lord of the Rings even though Tolkien, himself, chastised Lewis for his use of allegory.
The island could be Heaven, yeah I guess, but if it were, it sure isn’t perfect. Also, it could be Purgatory, but if it was, Protestants should have caught on LOOOOONNNNGGG ago that the show wouldn’t be theologically satisfying for them. Why does the finale all of a sudden have people up in arms? Also, the episode explaining the origin of Jacob and the Smoke Monster/MIB confuses the heck out of me. If Jacob was a Christ figure or a figure of good, then why is his “mother” an unabashed murderer/liar? Why did he appear so weak? Why was he not the first choice to guard the island? Nothing fits neatly into a Biblical box, so if you want allegory read Lewis or Francine Rivers, but don’t make Lost something it’s not.
Secondly, while some of the characters on Lost are blatantly spiritual/Christian/Catholic (Mr. Ekko and Rose), most of the characters do not seem to ascribe to any type of religion. Sure we can deduce that some are Muslim (Sayid), Buddhist (Jin and Sun), and Christian/Catholic (all of the Americans, Brits, and Australians), but we don’t really see any of them talking about their faith or acting on it.
Having said that, I cannot think of another secular show in my lifetime that has portrayed Christians so beautifully. Rose is portrayed as a woman of deep faith who trusts that her husband Bernard is alive, despite all odds. Mr. Ekko, though his past is sordid, is kind and good. Usually Christians are portrayed by movies, tv, and the media as idiots or as bigots. I can appreciate a show that, while not directly endorsing Christianity, at least respects it.
Finally, if Christians want Christ themes in movies and tv they need to be a part of making it happen. Why do we expect Hollywood to deliver Christian themes when by in large, Hollywood does not claim to be Christ-centered? Though Facing the Giants and Fireproof are not particularly well acted movies, I give props to Sherwood Baptist Church and Alex Kendrick for making Christ centered films. Also I give props to my brother in law for being a Christian film school student. I’m sure he will someday touch the world and the Church with his films.
What we can gain from Lost…
Too often Christians dismiss art of all kinds that is not directly religious. But I believe God can be experienced in all kinds of art, regardless of the artist. If in the end, we believe that God made the artist, then we believe that he enabled the artist to create the art in the first place. Though I don’t necessarily believe that Lost is an allegory, I do think there are many themes in Lost that we can learn from-too many to mention, but these are a few:
Redemption:
Lost reminds us that redemption is available to everyone regardless of their pasts. Most of the characters on Lost have really messy pasts, but the island gives them a new purpose for life. Some people accept their new purpose, while others resist it. We are all messed up, too and I believe that redemption is available to all men and women through faith in Jesus. Some of us will accept this with faith, while others will resist it.
Forgiveness/Reconciliation:
Lost reminds us of the importance of community, forgiveness, and reconciliation. Let’s think of all the bad relationships on the island that were eventually reconciled: Locke/Jack, Jack/Sawyer, Walt/Michael, Ben/Hurley, Shannon/Boone, Kate/Jack, Jin/Sun, Charlie/Claire…the list goes on. There is nothing on Earth more important than our relationships with God and people. In the end the characters on Lost learned this lesson.
Heaven:
I think the most moving scene in the whole series was Jack’s arrival in “Heaven.” Though, I disagree with Lost’s description of the afterlife, what a beautiful picture of Heaven it was. Imagine the reunion with all the people we’ve lost in life and the perfection that is Eternity with our Creator. It will be a place where all things are made right-where ailments are healed, and there is no sin or pain. It’s indescribable and incomprehensible, and last night I was reminded of how glorious eternity will be.
The reality of Good and Evil:
You can deny it all you want, but in the world, there is Good and there is Evil. Lost is a reminder that we will always be caught in the balance between these two realities. Sometimes, we won’t even know which side we’re on. Toward the end of Lost, it was difficult to know which side was evil and which side wasn’t. Our day-to-day life can be just as muddled. This is why it’s important, as a Believer, to be constantly praying for discernment to choose between good and bad, better and best.
In Conclusion…
I’ve said from the beginning that Lost is an amazing show, full of great acting, flawless writing, and spiritual undertones. It is not overtly Christian, nor do I believe it to be perfectly analogous to anything. It is creative, it is fiction, it is over.
Of course, we all have questions that were left unanswered. Why did pregnant women die on the island? What was the deal with Charles Widmore? Why were the Others kidnapping children in the first two seasons? What about Walt?
All in all, Lost has left me thinking deeply about the stuff of life and I can honestly say, I was deeply moved and satified by its finale.